Thursday, November 19, 2009
3:10 to Yuma
In the later version, Dan Evans tries to prove to his sons that he is brave and heroic, whereas in the earlier version Dan Evans only wants to earn the money so that he can save his ranch. This is a revision, because in the later film Dan’s kids do not respect him and in the earlier film Dan’s kids think the world of their father. In the 1957 version, Dan’s children hardly make an appearance at all. His wife, however, makes many appearances, from the beginning to when she rides to meet him in Contention to when she sees him in the train in the end. In the later film, the director must not have wanted to make the same point with Dan’s wife because she did not have nearly as much of a role as she did in the earlier version. Dan’s son takes to the forefront in the later version. This is a revision because in the earlier version the women act as the main “other” whereas in the later version the young boy acts as the “other”.
Another point of revision is the point of other races in the film. In the newer version, Asians worked to build the railroad and both an Apache and a Mexican were part of Wade’s gang. In the later version, the director wanted to show all of the different types of people in the west, especially the Chinese that built the railroads, whereas the older version did not care to show many other races at all. This is a strong point of revision, because it signifies that today people are more apt to show people of all race and creed to play a part in an event, whereas in the 1950s people were less apt to show others of different races.
3:10 to Yuma
The remake of 3:10 to Yuma had a very different plot because the director revised a lot of the aspects of the film. In the latter of 3:10 to Yuma many changes were made in the plot to revise this classic western. In the new film the character base was a mix of different races. The crew of outlaws had a Mexican sniper. During the scene when they are looking for Ben Wade they go through a rail road site with Asain workers. These characters were not present in the 1957 production of the movie where most people seen were Anglo-Saxon. Add a diverse cast is a revision of the western ideal. Children played a major role in 3:10 to Yuma. When Dan Evans’ son stuck up Ben Wade, a child in classic westerns never had the ability t overpower the bad alpha male.
The outlaws in 3:10 to Yuma were sociopaths. They killed without flinching, and were ruthless with betrayal. This is a revision because in the 1957 production the outlaws had a code. They did not look forward to killing; they tried to avoid because killing brought severe consequences. New technologies where used by the outlaws in the 2007 remake. The Mexican had a long barrel rifle with a long scope attached. Dynamite was also a weapon used by the alpha males in 3:10 to Yuma. These new technologies present the audience with intense action. This is a modern revision to most action movies.
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
3:10 to Yuma
The role of the female is a distinguishing characteristic which makes the remake a revisionist film. In the original film, when Dan and his two sons arrive home after watching the robbery and murder, his wife comes running out of the house looking dazed and confused. Dan does not seem to have the time of day to explain to his wife what has happened and looks to his young children to explain to their mother. Throughout the conversation, Alice expresses disproval that Dan did nothing to help. He claims it was not his place to intervene. In classic westerns the female is often dismissed by the alpha male, especially when she speaks. In the original film, Emmy is seen as an object to Ben, someone he can bribe with pearls.
In the classic Western, the alpha male cowboy bases his journeys off of his duty. He lives by a sense of duty based ethics, in which he only completes tasks he sees as necessary and required by him. At the beginning of the original film when the sheriff asks Dan to bring Ben Wade to the train Dan refuses and says, “That’s not my job, I ain’t no deputy.” He only later accepts because the cash reward is needed to save his farm. In the 2007 version places a greater emphasis on Dan Evan’s role as a father and husband. While in both films Dan accepts the task of escorting Ben to the 3:10 train to Yuma, it seems that in the latest film he does so out of duty to his family, to make money for his boys, not his farm. The 1958 film repeatedly stresses the fact Dan is losing money because his farm is suffering from the drought. Although he needs the money to support his family as well, it seems as though Dan in the 2007 film has a greater connection with his family. In classic western films the alpha male cowboy is not tied down to a home and a family. In the remake Dan’s son is instrumental in the completion of his father’s task. After Dan is shot it is his son who holds the gun to Ben to ensure he boards the train to Yuma. In the original of 3:10 to Yuma, Dan finishes his duty and rides the train with Ben to guarantee his arrival to the prision.
3:10 to Yuma
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
Unforgiven
Revisionism according to the New Oxford American Dictionary is “a policy of revision or modification…the theory or practice of revising one’s attitude to a previously accepted situation or point of view.” Freeman is one of the first prominent African American characters in the Western films we have seen. Freeman’s character Ned Logan is skilled with a gun however, he is able to pull the trigger, and fires a shot but he is unable to kill the man. For the first time in Westerns, the gun doesn’t solve issues. This revisionist film was an interesting contrast to the films we have seen thus far.
Unforgiven
We see an essence of revisionism n terms of the alpha male character, Munny, in contrast with his faithful partner, Ned. In classic Westerns, the alpha male cowboy, along with all other ruthless cowboys of the West, are generally white men. Ned Logan happens to be African American. This is the first time that a black man is given such an important role, especially important to the alpha male cowboy. It was Ned’s death that ultimately sparked the alpha cowboy to claim his revenge. Beforehand, the alpha cowboy was far from his glory days. We see him struggling with the farm in the beginning, just like he has trouble shooting the can from the tree at first. We no longer see an overbearing presence in terms of the alpha male cowboy, just like the villains seem to have more power.
If we take a look at the roles of women in the film, we are also presented with a seriously different representation of women from the classic Westerns. Traditionally, women are objects for the pleasure of men. They are in charge of the household, and spend their lifetime waiting for a man to wed her. However, in Unforgiven, we see a group of prostitutes who essentially are businesswomen. They might not have much power in comparison to men in town, but at least it’s not the typical background role of ignorance that women tend to represent.
Unforgiven
Munny was living in a farm raising two children and Logan left his wife to go with the Kid in the mission he proposed to them. At first both were doubtful about the decision but in the end they followed The Kid and continued in their mission.
Even though this movie shows the hugry side of cowboys it also shows us a new image of them. The soft side that Logan portrays when he leaves Kid and Munny after the first encounter with Little Bill and the law.
At the end of the movie, the real cowboy is shown. There is a scene which show the alpha male’s true nature. Killing a lo of cowboys without receiving a hit and later threatening everybody and scaring them so they would not come in his way. He is shown alone in the bar drinking whiskey with dead bodies around him. Unforgiven is a western which truly knows the real meaning of the alpha male cowboy.